On July 9, 1868, the 14th
Amendment was ratified. It amounts to the legal rebirth of America. Boiled
down, it provides us protections against state and local actions that take away
our liberty and property
and life (called due process), and ensures that
state and local laws treat us with equal protection.
It also defines citizenship. This means that
freed slaves were given full legal rights equal to whites; and also, anyone—
regardless of their parents’ ancestry or origin— was to be counted as an American
citizen if they are born on U.S. soil.
Given how polarized our nation is,
here is a brief summary of conservative and liberal rulings that have
interpreted the 14th Amendment.
Conservatives: State and local
governments must pay fair market value if either takes your property for a public purpose. Furthermore, if state
or local laws so restrict your property that you cannot enjoy or use it as you
wish, you can sue under the property provision of the 14th
Amendment.
Liberals: Separate but equal is not
constitutional; it violates the Equal Protection Clause. A woman has a due process
right (liberty) to have an abortion. Children
who are not legally in the U.S. have a right to free public education because
the Amendment refers to “any person,” not “any American citizen.” Gay people have a right to be legally married.
Though 150 years old today, the 14th
Amendment is still under construction as our nation figures out the core
meanings of liberty and equal
treatment.
No comments:
Post a Comment